AI visibility for title companies
Short answer
One Columbus answer shortlists five title companies, each in 1 of 3 sampled answers. It is "going on size, track record and local presence more than star ratings." All 3 answers say buyers can choose the title company. Itemized fees and a phone check of wiring instructions each appear in 2 of 3. On October 14, 2026, we asked whom to hire, how to choose, and what an owner's policy costs.
The AI Visibility Index: title companies
On October 14, 2026, two Claude profiles answered three questions. The questions were whom to hire in Columbus, how to choose, and what an owner's title policy costs. Only the hire question named Columbus. The choice answer asks "in which state?" The cost answer says "If you tell me the state." claude-argentum took the hire and cost questions. claude-vizaeo took the choice question. All three answers returned text. The choice answer says it was "written from memory, not checked against sources."
Who the models name
The hire answer shortlists five companies, each in 1 of 3 sampled answers. Title First Agency, owned by Stewart, fits "a standard home purchase or refinance." AmeriTitle has "the strongest Columbus review record I found." First American Title's Columbus office fits "a deal where the lender or the other side wants a national name." Empora Title fits "investors and anyone who wants to close remotely." Search2Close fits buyers who want a locally owned firm, as "an option rather than a first choice."
The same answer lists five more firms it "didn't check closely," each in 1 of 3: Valmer Land Title, Landsel Title, Great American Title, Scioto Title, and CLOSED Title.
The choice answer names four underwriters to ask about: First American, Fidelity National, Old Republic, and Stewart. First American and Stewart therefore appear in 2 of 3 answers, once as local offices or owners and once as underwriters. The cost answer names no company.
Where the models send clients
The state insurance department appears in 2 of 3 answers. The hire answer names the Ohio Department of Insurance license lookup "before you wire any money." The choice answer uses the state insurance department for license and complaint checks. The Better Business Bureau (BBB) appears in 2 of 3. The American Land Title Association (ALTA) appears in 2 of 3.
Redfin appears in 1 of 3, with ratings such as "4.6 out of 5 on Redfin from 18 reviews." BiggerPockets, the HouseCashin investor directory, and CB Insights each appear in 1 of 3. Bankrate appears in 1 of 3, for cost figures. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) appears in 1 of 3, for the combined-policy saving and the right to shop.
What the models judge on
The right to choose appears in 3 of 3. The hire and choice answers cite the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA). The cost answer says buyers can shop for title insurance apart from the mortgage. State-set premiums appear in 3 of 3. The hire answer says Ohio premiums follow filed rates, so "Compare the fees, not the insurance price." The choice answer says some states set the premium by law, and names Texas. The cost answer says some states regulate title costs with legally set rates. An itemized fee quote appears in 2 of 3. Wire fraud controls appear in 2 of 3. The hire answer calls wire fraud "the biggest real risk in this process."
A backing underwriter appears in 2 of 3. Remote closing appears in 2 of 3. Local experience appears in 2 of 3. An early title commitment appears in 2 of 3. Combined owner's and lender's policy pricing appears in 2 of 3.
Review counts appear in 1 of 3, with a caveat: "Public review data on title companies is thin (8 to 25 reviews each)." Founding dates appear in 1 of 3: 1956 for Title First, 2002 for Valmer, and 2020 for Empora. A Closing Protection Letter, errors and omissions insurance, and ALTA Best Practices each appear in 1 of 3. The cost answer gives "0.5% to 1% of the purchase price," citing Bankrate.
How to improve your AI visibility as a title company
AI access
Because the hire answer built its shortlist from pages it could fetch, publish your offices, underwriter, and closing options as plain text. Put your settlement fee schedule on a page too, since 2 of 3 answers compared fees. Fetch each page as a crawler would and confirm the fees appear as words.
AI business profile
Name your underwriter in the first line. State your Ohio Department of Insurance license number, your counties, and your closing types: purchase, refinance, investor, new construction, estate sale, or remote. Say whether you issue a Closing Protection Letter and hold ALTA Best Practices certification.
Identity tags
Use local business schema with the agency name, license number, and each office address. Add sameAs links to your Redfin, BBB, and Google profiles. Match the agency name to the state license record exactly.
Answer bank
Answer the state-set premiums that all 3 answers raised. Explain which fees you set yourself. The hire answer pointed to Ohio filed rates. Explain the reissue and simultaneous issue discounts. List the title problems that delay a closing and how you clear each one. Publish your wiring policy, including that you never change instructions by email.
Google profile
Choose a title company category and list each office separately. Ask buyers and agents to name their closer in reviews, since the hire answer weighed "your agent's experience with a specific closer." Reply to every review, including mixed ones.
Listing consistency
Since answers checked the state license lookup, BBB, Redfin, and investor directories, use one name on all of them. Match the parent company and underwriter on every profile. Close profiles for offices you no longer run.
Freshness and measurement
Update your fee schedule whenever it changes, and date it. Each quarter, ask the same three questions with your city in the prompt. Save the raw answers and count each company once per answer.
Title Companies-specific plays
- Grow review volume on Redfin, because the hire answer said Redfin and directory counts were too small to separate firms.
- Publish a wire fraud page that tells buyers which phone number to call, since 2 of 3 answers raised wire fraud.
- Explain RESPA in one paragraph: a seller cannot require a buyer to use your firm, and buyers may choose you.
- Show an itemized sample quote with premium, settlement fee, endorsements, and recording fees on separate lines.
- Offer an early title commitment and explain Schedule B exceptions in plain words.
- If an agent or lender owns part of your agency, publish your Affiliated Business Arrangement disclosure.
How this index is made
We asked three buyer questions to AI assistants through CLI engines on October 14, 2026. The public dataset stores each raw answer. Only one answer named local companies, and the choice answer ran from memory, so this snapshot is thin. Only the hire question named Columbus. The other two named no city or state. claude-argentum answered the hire and cost questions. claude-vizaeo answered the choice question. A 17 October 2026 hire answer names Northwest Title, Valmer, Title First, and Columbus Title Agency. It names Empora and CLOSED for investors. It drops AmeriTitle, First American, and Search2Close. That wave's choice answer had web search denied. This page stays on the 14 October batch. Later waves refresh it as a time series. The Index methodology page gives the full method.
About Vizaeo
Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.