AI Visibility for Search Engine Optimization Agencies
Short answer
Both usable answers judged agencies on measured business results, the named person doing the work, and a refusal to guarantee rankings. The choice answer graded agencies against Google's hiring guidance and spam policies. We asked three buyer questions on 2026-10-14, withdrew one answer that did not answer its question, and counted the other two by hand.
The AI Visibility Index: search engine optimization agencies
On 2026-10-14 we asked 3 buyer questions about search engine optimization (SEO) agencies to Claude and Grok. Only the naming question named Boston, MA. Claude answered that question from memory, with web search blocked. Grok answered the choice question and checked sources. The cost answer was withdrawn because it did not price the service, so every count below is out of 2.
Who the models name
The naming answer listed four agencies, each in 1 of 2. It checked no sources. Treat these names as memory, not a live list.
- Brafton, "Headquartered in Boston," for content-led SEO. The answer rated its confidence High.
- Overthink Group, a small firm for business-to-business (B2B) software, where "Senior people do the work." Confidence: Medium.
- Velir, a Somerville agency, for SEO tied to a site rebuild or migration. Confidence: high that it exists, medium on its SEO depth.
- Boston Web Marketing, a smaller-budget local SEO option. Confidence: Medium-low.
The answer said web search was blocked, so every name came "from memory up to mid-2026." The choice answer named no agency.
Where the models send clients
- Google's own documentation: 1 of 2. The choice answer graded agencies against Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page, the spam policies, and Search Essentials.
- Google Search Console, as the place to check results: 1 of 2.
- Clutch reviews: 1 of 2. The naming answer said it would check firms there if search were allowed.
- Past-client calls and case studies: 2 of 2.
- The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and econsumer.gov, for deceived buyers: 1 of 2.
The naming answer distrusted ranking lists: "The 'best agencies' lists are mostly paid placements."
What the models judge on
- Measured business outcomes: 2 of 2. The choice answer wanted leads, calls, or sales checked in Search Console.
- Before-and-after case studies: 1 of 2. The naming answer wanted organic traffic and leads before and after, and said "Rankings alone don't count."
- The named person doing the work: 2 of 2.
- No guaranteed rankings: 2 of 2.
- Link practices: 2 of 2. Both answers warned against bulk or bought links.
- Contract terms: 2 of 2. The naming answer preferred month-to-month or a 90-day trial "over a 12-month lock-in."
- Fit to the client's type: 2 of 2, such as B2B software, local service, or e-commerce.
- Client ownership of accounts and content: 1 of 2.
- Confirmed Boston office: 1 of 2.
How to improve your AI visibility as a search engine optimization agency
The naming answer worked from memory and graded its own confidence by firm. Clear, readable facts on your site give an assistant something firmer than memory.
AI access
Open your robots file and allow GPTBot, ClaudeBot, and PerplexityBot. Put case results in page text, not chart images. The naming answer wanted traffic and leads before and after. Note that the choice answer cited Google as saying no llms.txt file is needed. Skip gimmicks and keep pages readable.
AI business profile
Say who you serve in the first sentence. The naming answer sorted agencies by B2B software, content output, site migrations, and local SEO. Name your office address and city. The answer gave Somerville and Boston as separate facts. Name the people who do the weekly work.
Identity tags
Add Organization schema with your legal name, office address, founding year, and staff as Person entries. Link your Clutch profile with sameAs. The naming answer named Clutch as its check.
Answer bank
Answer the questions the usable answers told buyers to ask.
- What would you change first on this site, and why?
- What does the monthly report show, and can the client check it in Search Console?
- Who does the work each week, by name?
- How do you earn links? The choice answer said to ask "where those links come from."
- What are the contract length and notice period?
- Who owns the domain, analytics, and Google Business Profile?
Google profile
This sample never cited Google Maps as a place to find an agency. The choice answer still said the client should own the Google Business Profile. Use the internet marketing service category, the same address as your site, and real staff photos.
Listing consistency
Match your name, address, and service list across your site, Clutch, LinkedIn, and any agency directory. The naming answer rated its confidence that each firm is in Boston and still does SEO work. Consistent current listings answer both questions.
Freshness and measurement
Date every case study and the report sample. Each quarter, ask the three buyer questions again, with your city in each, and save the answers.
Search Engine Optimization Agencies-specific plays
- Publish a sample report a client can check in Search Console. The choice answer rejected a report the client cannot reproduce there.
- State what you refuse to do. Both usable answers disqualified ranking guarantees and bought links. Put your own refusals in writing.
- Put client ownership in the contract summary. The choice answer wanted domain, analytics, and Search Console "in your company's name."
- Offer a short entry point. Both usable answers favored a trial, a diagnostic, or month-to-month terms. Describe yours plainly.
- Explain your AI search work in Google's terms. The choice answer said that work should be "the same foundational work," measured in Search Console.
- Treat this as recurring work. Clients renew monthly, so publish your reporting cadence and exit terms.
How this index is made
We asked three buyer questions to Claude and Grok through command-line engines on 2026-10-14. We stored every answer raw in a public data set. The cost answer was withdrawn because it did not price the service, so this page counts 2. The sample is thin. Web search was blocked for the naming answer, so its agency names rest on memory. Only the naming question named Boston. We refresh the data set in waves, so this page is one snapshot of a time series. The Index methodology page explains the full method.
About Vizaeo
Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.