AI Visibility for Plastic Surgeons in New York, NY
Short answer
The two sampled answers shared no recommended surgeon. The naming answer listed 8 procedure-specific names from training data, and the choosing answer listed board checks and fee bands instead. Vizaeo asked two English buyer questions on 2026-10-13 and tallied the raw answers by hand.
The AI Visibility Index: Plastic surgeons in New York
On 2026-10-13, Vizaeo asked two English questions, one per engine, so every count below is out of 2. claude-vizaeo answered "Who are the best Plastic Surgeons in New York? Name the ones you would recommend and say why." claude-argentum answered "How do I choose a good plastic surgeon in New York? What should I look for, what should I avoid, and what do they usually charge there?" Because the claude-vizaeo session blocked web search, the naming answer used training data through mid-2026.
Who the models name
The naming answer recommended 8 surgeons. The choosing answer recommended none. Dr. Sam Rizk is the only person in both answers, and the second mention is a price page.
- Dr. Eduardo Rodriguez, NYU Langone: 1 of 2. Face and trauma reconstruction, a chair role, and face transplants, including 2020.
- Dr. Babak Mehrara, Memorial Sloan Kettering: 1 of 2. Breast reconstruction after cancer, and lymphedema research.
- Dr. Constance Chen, private practice: 1 of 2. Tissue breast reconstruction. No borough given.
- Dr. Alan Matarasso, Manhattan: 1 of 2. Tummy tuck and liposuction. Former ASPS president.
- Dr. Andrew Jacono, Manhattan: 1 of 2. Deep-plane facelift. Facial plastic board, not the general plastic surgery board.
- Dr. Sherrell Aston, Manhattan Eye, Ear and Throat Hospital: 1 of 2. Facelift. The naming answer said to confirm Aston still sees patients.
- Dr. Haideh Hirmand, Manhattan: 1 of 2. Revision rhinoplasty.
- Dr. Sam Rizk, Manhattan: 2 of 2. Rhinoplasty with Hirmand in the naming answer. A facelift price page only in the choosing answer.
- NYU Langone, Memorial Sloan Kettering, and NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell: 1 of 2 each, for cancer, trauma, and high-risk care.
- Gotham Plastic Surgery: 1 of 2. Facelift marketing page, not a surgeon to book.
Where the models send clients
- American Board of Plastic Surgery (ABPS): 2 of 2. abplasticsurgery.org in the naming answer. ABPS certification by name in the choosing answer.
- ASPS Find a Surgeon on plasticsurgery.org: 1 of 2, for membership, in the choosing answer.
- Facial plastic board: 2 of 2. abfprs.org in the naming answer only.
- State physician profile: 2 of 2. nydoctorprofile.com in the naming answer. Department of Health profile, with no URL, in the choosing answer.
- AAAASF: 2 of 2. AAAHC and The Joint Commission: 1 of 2, under Public Health Law 230-d.
- Office of the Professions license lookup: 1 of 2.
- ASPS training, accreditation, and 2024 cost pages: 1 of 2. The choosing answer said the cost PDF returned a 404, so the figures came from search results.
- The Aesthetic Society: 2 of 2. A past presidency in the naming answer. A credentials article in the choosing answer.
- Gotham Plastic Surgery, the Rizk price page, and Science Insights: 1 of 2 each.
- New York Magazine "Best Doctors" and Castle Connolly: 1 of 2. The naming answer offered both only if a later search ran, and used neither.
- RealSelf, Yelp, Zocdoc, and Google: 0 of 2.
What the models judge on
- ABPS status, the facial board, an accredited room, hospital privileges, procedure volume, similar-patient photos, and a discipline check: 2 of 2.
- The naming answer wanted unedited photos. The choosing answer said "cosmetic surgeon" is not a protected title.
- Public Health Law 230-d, for sedation, general anesthesia, or any liposuction: 1 of 2.
- Procedure fit, academic backup, society office, and whether the surgeon still sees patients: 1 of 2.
- Training time: 1 of 2. ABPS-certified ASPS members train at least 6 years after medical school. At least 3 of those years are plastic surgery residency.
- Anesthesia by a physician anesthesiologist or a certified registered nurse anesthetist, not "the nurse": 1 of 2.
- Avoid, choosing answer only: a cosmetic-surgery board as the main credential, an unaccredited suite, a same-day booking, and a today-only discount.
- Also avoid a price far under the ranges, and a long combination sold to save money.
- Also avoid medical tourism, Instagram reach alone, and a quote that hides inclusions.
- Price, choosing answer only: 2024 ASPS national surgeon fees, with anesthesia, the operating room, implants, and garments extra. Facelift 12,000 to 19,000 US dollars, tummy tuck 8,000 to 13,500, rhinoplasty 7,500 to 12,500, breast augmentation 4,575 to 8,000, upper eyelid 3,000 to 5,500, and lower eyelid 3,709 to 6,500.
- New York, same answer: no independent survey. Marketing pages quoted a full facelift at 10,000 to 70,000 US dollars, top facelift surgeons at 25,000 to 100,000 and up, and an all-in first rhinoplasty at 9,000 to 20,000. A labeled guess put a well-regarded Manhattan surgeon at about 1.5 to 3 times the national surgeon fee after anesthesia and facility fees, with celebrity-tier facelifts above it. Cosmetic surgery is almost never covered. Get an itemized quote from 2 or 3 ABPS-certified surgeons.
How to improve your AI visibility as a plastic surgeon in New York
Because the two answers shared no recommended surgeon, publish the checks both answers named.
AI access
Allow GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and Google-Extended in robots.txt. Put the board, the hospital, and the suite accreditor in HTML. Put the yearly procedure count in text on the procedure page.
AI business profile
Give each surgeon a page with the board's full name. Both answers separated ABPS from the facial plastic board. Name the privileging hospital and the borough.
Identity tags
Mark the practice as a Physician in schema.org, and set medicalSpecialty to PlasticSurgery. Add a Person entry, the street, and the suite. Link abplasticsurgery.org, plasticsurgery.org, or nydoctorprofile.com with sameAs only when the listing exists.
Answer bank
Publish a page for trauma, breast reconstruction, tissue reconstruction, body contouring, facelift, and rhinoplasty. Answer candidacy, risks, revision cost, recovery, and who gives anesthesia. Publish an all-in quote with surgeon, anesthesia, operating room, implants, and garments on separate lines.
Google profile
Set the Plastic surgeon category and the real borough. Add each procedure as its own service, named as on the procedure page. Use photos that match the consult gallery. Reply to reviews without confirming the reviewer is a patient or mentioning their procedure, to stay inside patient-privacy rules.
Listing consistency
Keep the name, suite, and phone identical on the site, Google, abplasticsurgery.org, plasticsurgery.org, and nydoctorprofile.com. Match the Office of the Professions record. The choosing answer quoted marketing price pages, so the public fee has to match the consult quote.
Freshness and measurement
Update the page the week a surgeon cuts back or changes hospitals. Re-ask the two questions above and write down the sample size.
Plastic surgeon-specific plays in New York
- Academic privileges. The naming answer sent cancer, trauma, and high-risk care to three academic centers. If you hold academic privileges, name the center and the case types you take there.
- Public Health Law 230-d. Name AAAHC, AAAASF, or The Joint Commission, plus the expiry, when the suite uses sedation or any liposuction.
- Board by full name. The naming answer put Dr. Andrew Jacono on the facial plastic board, not the general plastic surgery board. State which board certifies you, by full name, on every procedure page.
- Your own all-in fee. The choosing answer found no city survey, then guessed about 1.5 to 3 times the national surgeon fee. Publish your own all-in New York fee instead of letting a national multiple stand in for it.
- Name the borough. The naming answer set Matarasso, Jacono, Hirmand, and Rizk in Manhattan, and gave Chen no borough. Say Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, or Staten Island if that is the office.
- A considered consult. The choosing answer said to see 2 or 3 ABPS-certified surgeons and to refuse a today-only discount.
How this index is made
Vizaeo asked two English buyer questions through command-line AI engines on 2026-10-13. claude-vizaeo answered the naming question, and claude-argentum answered the choosing question. Both are Claude, run under two accounts. Because that naming session blocked web search, those names came from training data. Raw answers sit in a public dataset and refresh in waves, so this page is one snapshot of a thin sample. Read every count as out of 2, and read the full method on the Index methodology page.
About Vizaeo
Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.