AI Visibility for Plastic Surgeons in Cincinnati, OH
Short answer
One answer named 19 Cincinnati surgeons and matched the names to operations and peer lists. The other answer named no surgeon and printed an unverified fee table from memory. Vizaeo asked two English buyer questions on 2026-10-22 and tallied both raw answers by hand.
The AI Visibility Index: Plastic Surgeons in Cincinnati
Because the sample is two answers, every count below is out of 2. Vizaeo asked the questions in English on 2026-10-22, one question to each engine.
grok took the naming question: "Who are the best Plastic Surgeons in Cincinnati?" That answer searched peer lists and hospital pages. claude-vizaeo took the choosing question about how to choose, what to avoid, and what surgeons charge. That session denied web search, so the fee table came from memory.
Who the models name
The choosing answer named no surgeon. Every name below is 1 of 2, from the naming answer only.
- Bianca Chin, RestoreMD and The Christ Hospital: flap breast reconstruction, on Castle Connolly since 2020 and the 2026 Cincinnati Magazine list.
- Kayla Smith, TriHealth at Good Samaritan: implant reconstruction and cosmetic breast, on both of those lists.
- Neilendu Kundu, Mercy Health Kenwood, 4750 East Galbraith Road: 2026 magazine list. Mercy shows 4.9 out of 5 from 271 ratings.
- Donna Krummen, 8211 Cornell Road: Castle Connolly since 2015. A U.S. News page dated July 21, 2026 shows 5 out of 5 from 134 reviews. Krummen is absent from the 2026 magazine plastic page.
- Steven Robinson and Robert Hummel, The Plastic Surgery Group, 4030 Smith Road: Castle Connolly. Robinson has Christ Hospital privileges. Hummel trained at the University of Cincinnati.
- Richard Williams and Ryan Wilson, same group: 2026 magazine list. Robinson and Hummel are absent from that 2026 category page.
- Lawrence Kurtzman, 5050 East Galbraith Road: 2026 magazine list. The practice site states board certification in 1991.
- Allison Lied, Holzapfel + Lied, 8044 Montgomery Road: 2026 magazine list. The site states board certification in 2006.
- Allison Holzapfel and Nicole Starr, same office: 2026 magazine list, through facial plastic boards rather than the plastic surgery board.
- Alexander Donath, 7763 Montgomery Road: the first face name in that answer. The answer cited a 14th Castle Connolly year and a WebMD score of 5.0 from 85 ratings.
- Jeffrey Harmon: 2026 magazine list, and a New York facial-plastic fellowship with Andrew Jacono. Jacono is not a Cincinnati surgeon. The answer named Jacono only as that teacher.
- Brian Pan, Cincinnati Children's: cleft lip, palate, and craniosynostosis. Division director, 2026 magazine list.
- Ryan Gobble, UC Health: reconstruction, including breast and face. Not on either peer list in that answer. A U.S. News page dated July 21, 2026 shows 4.8 out of 5 from 77 reviews.
- Mark Mandell-Brown: 2026 magazine list. The site describes facial plastic and cosmetic-surgery boards, plus a past presidency of the American Academy of Cosmetic Surgery. The answer treated CityBeat and Enquirer reader awards as a weak stand-in for the plastic surgery board on reconstruction.
- Jean Loftus: the practice site states board certification. Healthgrades shows 5.0 from 591 reviews, last verified October 13, 2026. The answer would not place Loftus ahead of the peer-listed names.
- Sonu Jain: still on some Cincinnati pages, including Castle Connolly. Healthgrades, verified October 15, 2026, lists a Columbus office. The answer would not book Jain in Cincinnati without confirmation.
- The Christ Hospital, UC Health, TriHealth, and Mercy Health: 2 of 2. Both answers named those four hospitals.
- Good Samaritan, RestoreMD, The Plastic Surgery Group, Holzapfel + Lied, and Cincinnati Children's: 1 of 2.
Where the models send clients
- American Board of Plastic Surgery, including abplasticsurgery.org: 2 of 2.
- American Society of Plastic Surgeons finder or plasticsurgery.org: 2 of 2. The naming answer said the finder does not re-check the certificate.
- Castle Connolly and Cincinnati Magazine's 2026 Top Doctors list: 1 of 2.
- Healthgrades, U.S. News, and WebMD: 1 of 2.
- Ohio license search at elicense.ohio.gov: 1 of 2.
- AAAASF, AAAHC, and The Joint Commission: 1 of 2, named only in the choosing answer.
- CityBeat and the Enquirer, as reader awards one office publicizes: 1 of 2. The naming answer discounted those polls for reconstruction.
- American Board of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery: 1 of 2, for the Holzapfel + Lied face surgeons.
What the models judge on
- A certificate from the American Board of Plastic Surgery, confirmed by the reader: 2 of 2.
- A surgeon matched to the operation: 2 of 2 as a rule. The naming answer separated flap reconstruction, implant breast work, and face-only practice.
- Hospital privileges for the operation: 2 of 2.
- Peer lists over reader polls: 1 of 2. Chin and Smith are the two plastic surgeons on both Castle Connolly and the 2026 magazine list.
- Who holds the knife, whether a fellow assists, and whether the room is a hospital or an accredited office: 1 of 2.
- A clean Ohio license, a named anesthesia clinician, two or three consults, and a written revision policy: 1 of 2.
- The choosing answer printed national fee ranges from memory and labeled the Cincinnati figures low confidence. That answer named no local fee page.
- The choosing answer rejected a same-day discount, a price far under other quotes, and a long stack of procedures.
- That answer also rejected a choice made from Instagram alone.
How to improve your AI visibility as a plastic surgeon in Cincinnati
Because the naming answer weighed two peer lists, put those listings where a later probe can see them.
AI access
Allow GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and Google-Extended in robots.txt. Keep the biography, the street address, and the hospital role in HTML. The naming answer had to reconcile two addresses for Bianca Chin.
AI business profile
Say the operation first: flap reconstruction, implant breast work, adult cosmetics, face only, or cleft care. Put the street in the first paragraph. This sample used Reading Road, Auburn Avenue, Cornell Road, Smith Road, East Galbraith Road, and Montgomery Road.
Identity tags
Mark the practice as a medical clinic and the surgeon as a physician in schema.org. Add sameAs links to the board record and to elicense.ohio.gov. When Castle Connolly or the 2026 Cincinnati Magazine list includes the surgeon, link that page.
Answer bank
Answer what this sample told clients to ask. Who holds the knife? Which hospital privileges the operation among Christ, UC Health, TriHealth, Mercy, and Cincinnati Children's? What is the all-in price? The choosing answer could not verify a Cincinnati fee.
Google profile
Use the Plastic Surgeon category, or a face category for face-only work. Match the profile address to the booking office. One profile per real door avoids the Chin split between a magazine line and a hospital line.
Listing consistency
Use one spelling on the site, the Ohio license, the board lookup, Healthgrades, U.S. News, and WebMD. The naming answer read those ratings and still kept a large review count behind the peer list.
Freshness and measurement
Date the biography. The naming answer refused a Cincinnati booking when the current office looked like Columbus. Re-ask both questions after a move.
Plastic surgeon-specific plays in Cincinnati
- Link both peer lists. Chin and Smith sat on Castle Connolly and the 2026 magazine list.
- Write the facial board for Donath, Harmon, Holzapfel, and Starr. The naming answer kept that certificate apart from the plastic surgery board.
- Give cleft care a separate page. Brian Pan entered through Cincinnati Children's.
- Publish one booking address. The naming answer found two doors for Chin.
- Say whether a moved surgeon still sees patients in Cincinnati. The Jain note pointed at a Columbus office.
How this index is made
Vizaeo asked two English buyer questions through command-line engines on 2026-10-22. grok searched and named the surgeons above from peer lists and hospital pages. claude-vizaeo had no web search, named no surgeon, and labeled local fees as low confidence. Raw answers sit in a public dataset and refresh in waves, so this page is one snapshot of a thin, two-answer sample. The full method lives on the Index methodology page.
About Vizaeo
Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.