Feed it to your favorite LLM

The AI Visibility Index

AI Visibility for Personal Injury Lawyers in Columbus, OH

Short answer

In Columbus, one sampled answer named eight lead plaintiff lawyers, led by Gerald Leeseberg. It backed them mostly with Super Lawyers and Best Lawyers listings and two newspaper-reported verdicts. Both answers sent clients to the Ohio Supreme Court attorney directory. Vizaeo asked 2 buyer questions in English to 2 AI engines on 2026-10-18 and tallied the raw answers by hand.

The AI Visibility Index: Personal injury lawyers in Columbus

Vizaeo asked 2 questions in English on 2026-10-18. The grok engine got the naming question: who are the best personal injury lawyers in Columbus, and why. The claude-vizaeo engine got the choosing question: what to look for, what to avoid, and what lawyers charge there. The sample is 2 answers. The naming answer searched the web. The choosing answer had no web access and said so.

Who the models name

Each lawyer below was named in 1 of 2 sampled answers, the naming answer. It ranked the first three as its calls, in order.

  • Gerald Leeseberg, with Craig Tuttle, at Leeseberg Tuttle. Named first, for medical cases, on a Dispatch-reported Franklin County verdict.
  • Michael J. Rourke at Rourke & Blumenthal. Named for crashes, products, and medical negligence. The answer also named Timothy Mahler there.
  • Mark E. Defossez at The Donahey Law Firm. Named for medical, crash, workplace, nursing-home, and product cases. The answer also named Gordon D. Evans II and Danny Newman Jr. there.
  • David I. Shroyer at Colley Shroyer Abraham, for medical mistakes.
  • John Fitch at The Fitch Law Firm, for childhood sexual abuse claims.
  • J. Scott Bowman at Geiser & Bowman, for truck and crash cases.
  • Roger Soroka at Soroka & Associates, "when the defendant is a trucking company."
  • Zachary Schiff at Schiff & Associates, for an ordinary car crash. The answer said the trial firms "often turn down smaller cases."

The choosing answer named no firm.

Where the models send clients

  • Ohio Supreme Court attorney directory: 2 of 2.
  • Super Lawyers: 1 of 2, cited for nearly every name, with year ranges.
  • Best Lawyers: 1 of 2.
  • The Columbus Dispatch: 1 of 2, as "the independent record" of a verdict.
  • Justia, Martindale, cleveland.com, and Nolo: 1 of 2 each.
  • Columbus Bar Association lawyer referral service: 1 of 2.

The naming answer, in 1 of 2, said "Google-review lists and 'top 10' sites mostly track advertising." It discounted firm-reported figures it could not match to a news story.

What the models judge on

  • Trial experience: 2 of 2.
  • Who will handle and try the case: 2 of 2.
  • Fit with the case type: 2 of 2.
  • A contingency fee that rises after suit: 2 of 2. The choosing answer gave about 33 percent before suit and about 40 percent after.
  • Meeting at least two lawyers: 2 of 2.
  • The two-year injury deadline and the one-year medical claim deadline: 2 of 2.
  • A license and discipline check: 2 of 2.
  • Skepticism of advertising-driven signals: 2 of 2. The naming answer doubted ad-driven lists. The choosing answer doubted "big firms that advertise a lot."
  • Board certification in civil trial advocacy: 1 of 2.
  • Years of peer recognition: 1 of 2.
  • Verdicts confirmed by a newspaper or court opinion: 1 of 2.
  • Results in Franklin County "in the last five years": 1 of 2.
  • Medical lien reduction: 1 of 2.
  • A written fee agreement and a closing statement: 1 of 2.
  • Extra notice rules for a city, the state, or the Central Ohio Transit Authority (COTA): 1 of 2.

How to improve your AI visibility as a personal injury lawyer in Columbus

AI access

Because the naming answer checked verdicts against the Dispatch, your own record needs readable text. Allow GPTBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and Google-Extended in robots.txt. Publish Franklin County Common Pleas results as HTML, with the court, year, and case number.

AI business profile

Write one plain page on the cases you take: I-270 Outerbelt and I-71 crashes, trucking wrecks on the I-70 corridor, COTA bus claims, or medical cases. Name the lawyer who tries each type. Say whether you accept smaller crash cases.

Identity tags

Mark the firm as LegalService and each lawyer as Person. Point each sameAs link to the Ohio Supreme Court directory, Super Lawyers, and Best Lawyers. List every partner by name. The naming answer named second lawyers at three firms.

Answer bank

Write short pages for the questions the choosing answer raised. Cover the one-year medical claim deadline, the notice letter, and COTA claims. Explain Ohio's solicitation limits after a crash, which the choosing answer hedged with "I believe." Open each page with a one-paragraph answer a model can lift.

Google profile

Use "Personal injury attorney" as the primary category. List a downtown, Dublin, or Westerville office only where staff work. Ask clients to name the case type in reviews, such as "truck crash on 270." Answer reviews without case facts.

Listing consistency

Match name, address, and phone across the Ohio Supreme Court directory, Super Lawyers, Best Lawyers, Justia, and Martindale. The naming answer quoted suite numbers and a Justia phone line. One stale suite splits your record.

Freshness and measurement

Post each verdict with its case number within a week. Re-ask both probe questions monthly in at least two assistants. Log which lawyers appear and which sources the answers cite.

Personal injury lawyer plays in Columbus

  • Get your verdict into the record. The naming answer trusted Dispatch reports over firm write-ups. Send verdict notices to local legal press, and post the case number.
  • Label firm-reported figures. The naming answer called one firm's recovery total "advertising copy." Pair every dollar figure with a court or case number.
  • Name your lane. The naming answer matched each lawyer to a case type in a table. State your lane on the first screen.
  • Serve the smaller crash. The naming answer sent ordinary wrecks to a firm that "actually returns calls." Publish response times and the case sizes you take.
  • Write for game days. Guidance: Ohio State home games pack campus roads. Date a page on pedestrian and rideshare claims near campus and the Short North.

How this index is made

Vizaeo asks AI assistants the questions clients ask, through command line engines, on the dataset date. The answers are stored raw in a public dataset and refreshed in waves. This page is one snapshot of a time series. This cell holds only 2 answers, and only the naming answer had web access. Treat every count here as thin. The full method lives on the Index methodology page.

About Vizaeo

Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.