Feed it to your favorite LLM

The AI Visibility Index

AI Visibility for Orthodontists in Columbus, OH

Short answer

Only 1 of 2 answers named Columbus orthodontists. That naming answer started with four practices and added Dr. Frank Cordray for a hard bite. Vizaeo asked 2 English questions on 2026-10-18 and tallied the raw answers.

The AI Visibility Index: Orthodontists in Columbus

Vizaeo asked 2 English questions on 2026-10-18, one per engine. Every count below is out of 2. grok answered "Who are the best Orthodontists in Columbus? Name the ones you would recommend and say why." It used a 2021 peer list plus recent reviews. claude-vizaeo answered "How do I choose a good orthodontist in Columbus? What should I look for, what should I avoid, and what do they usually charge there?" Search was blocked. Those costs are unchecked estimates. It assumed Columbus, Ohio.

Who the models name

Every private name below is in 1 of 2. The choosing answer named no private doctor.

  • Dr. Brandon Cook, Cook Orthodontics of Dublin, 5152 Blazer Pkwy. You see him, not a rotating associate. Ohio State orthodontic residency, finished in 2004. The office says he is an ABO diplomate. On the 2021 peer list. Only in Dublin since 2021. Healthgrades 4.9 from 184 reviews, verified October 3, 2026. Birdeye 5.0 from 713 Google reviews.
  • Dr. Amin Mason, Polaris Orthodontic Center, 1079 Polaris Pkwy. His site says ABO diplomate. Ohio State dentistry, a Kentucky craniofacial fellowship, then Colorado for the certificate and master's. On the 2021 peer list. Healthgrades 5.0 from 126 reviews, 99 percent five stars, verified October 15, 2026. An April 2026 rollup showed 588 reviews at 5 stars. Invisalign Premier. The naming answer picked him for an adult, a hard bite, or aligners with one owner.
  • Dr. Jesse Carmen and Dr. Ron Carmen, Carmen Orthodontics, 5225 E. Main St, plus three other offices. Ron opened in 1978 after Case Western. Jesse finished orthodontics there in 2012. Both are on the 2021 peer list. Jesse's Invisalign Diamond badge is volume, not a board exam. The naming answer found no ABO claim for either doctor. The Columbus office had about 767 reviews at 5 stars in April 2026. The practice claims more than 1,500 five-star reviews across offices. Ask for Jesse or Ron, and ask who adjusts.
  • Dr. Jeffrey Shirck, Shirck Orthodontics, in Westerville, New Albany, Powell, Newark, and Pataskala. Degrees from Ohio State, including craniofacial biology. He worked in the craniofacial clinic at Nationwide Children's during training. On the 2021 peer list. Westerville is about 4.9 from roughly 700 reviews. His Healthgrades score is 4.6 from 81, so the office and the doctor do not match. His bio does not say board-certified. Associate Dr. Morgan Segall was an Ohio State chief resident and also worked in that cleft clinic.
  • Dr. Frank Cordray, Worthington and Grove City, for a hard bite. Board-certified in 1991. He has taught at Ohio State since 1986 and also teaches at West Virginia University. On the 2021 peer list. More than 39 years in practice. More cautious about clear aligners than the high-volume offices.
  • Ohio State University College of Dentistry clinic: named in 1 of 2, by the choosing answer, as a lower fee with residents and longer visits.
  • SmileDirectClub: named in 1 of 2 as a mail-order firm that shut down in December 2023, not as a referral.

Where the models send clients

  • Columbus Parent, May 5, 2022, reprinting the 2021 topDentists survey: 1 of 2. Dentists voted. Nobody pays to be listed. The list is about five years old, that answer said.
  • Healthgrades, Birdeye, and Google: 1 of 2.
  • Yelp: 1 of 2. Lists there sit on about 15 to 20 reviews, so a small office can outrank a busy one.
  • ABO as a credential to ask about: 2 of 2. Neither answer linked an ABO locator.
  • AAO tool at aaoinfo.org: 1 of 2, the choosing answer.
  • The naming answer did not open Ohio State Dental Board records. It ignored pages that mixed in Columbus, Indiana.

What the models judge on

A finished residency: 2 of 2. The choosing answer said 2 to 3 more years. ABO as a plus: 2 of 2. The naming answer found it for Cook, Mason, and Cordray, and not for the Carmens or on Shirck's bio.

Side of town, and visits you can keep: 2 of 2. The choosing answer said 12 to 30 months, every 6 to 10 weeks, with before-school or after-school hours. A free first visit: 2 of 2. Two or more consults: 2 of 2.

Review patterns, not a perfect score: 2 of 2. Read the 2-star and 3-star notes for billing, rushed visits, or turnover: 1 of 2.

Invisalign Diamond counts cases, not a board exam: 1 of 2. Office stars can disagree with doctor stars: 1 of 2. Ask who adjusts, whether they pull teeth, and whether ABO is current: 1 of 2.

An itemized quote for retainers, emergencies, and refinements: 1 of 2. Age 7 can be watching only: 1 of 2. Same-day pressure: 1 of 2.

Choosing-answer bands, in US dollars, were not checked live. Confidence was moderate. It assumed Columbus sits near, or a bit under, the national average. Metal about 4,500 to 7,000. Ceramic about 5,000 to 7,500. Aligners about 4,500 to 7,500. Limited treatment about 2,000 to 4,000. Retainers, if excluded, about 200 to 600 a set. Insurance often pays a lifetime maximum of about 1,000 to 2,500, mostly for children. Ohio Medicaid, in that answer, covers children only when the bite is medically necessary.

How to improve your AI visibility as an orthodontist in Columbus

Because the peer list is about five years old, date it apart from the review counts.

AI access

Allow GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and Google-Extended in robots.txt. Put the residency year, the ABO status, and the license number in HTML. The naming answer never opened the Ohio State Dental Board.

AI business profile

Say who adjusts at that address. Carmen has four offices. Shirck lists Newark and Pataskala too. If you show an Invisalign badge, say it counts starts. That is how Jesse Carmen's badge was read. If Nationwide Children's is training only, say so.

Identity tags

Mark the practice as Dentist in schema.org, with "Columbus, Ohio." Add one Person entry per doctor. Show ABO only when that bio claims it. Use a separate page for Dublin, Polaris, Westerville, Worthington, Grove City, and Pataskala.

Answer bank

Put retainers, emergencies, and refinements in one quote. State the consult fee. Say which movements you will not do with aligners. Say whether you file Ohio Medicaid when a child's bite is medically necessary. Say the exam is in the chair. SmileDirectClub shut down in December 2023.

Google profile

Use the Orthodontist category and the suburb. Show the office score and the doctor score when they disagree. That was the Shirck split. Do not lean on a Yelp list of about 15 to 20 reviews.

Listing consistency

A Newark page is not a Westerville page. Grove City is not Worthington. The Ohio State clinic is not a faculty member's private door.

Freshness and measurement

The Columbus Parent reprint is dated May 5, 2022. Do not call that 2021 survey this year's vote. Re-ask both questions. This sample is 2 answers.

Orthodontist-specific plays in Columbus

  • Date the peer list. The 2021 topDentists survey was the independent signal. Review counts were the recent one.
  • Keep the state in the title. Both answers had to rule out another Columbus.
  • Say whether ABO is claimed. The naming answer found it for Cook, Mason, and Cordray only.
  • Point at the school clinic on purpose. The choosing answer named the Ohio State clinic as the lower fee, with more time in the chair.

How this index is made

Vizaeo asked two English buyer questions through command-line engines on 2026-10-18. grok took the naming question and cited the peer list, review sites, and practice bios. claude-vizaeo took the choosing question with search blocked, so its prices are unchecked ranges. Raw answers sit in a public dataset and refresh in waves, so this page is one snapshot. Two answers is a thin sample. The full method lives on the Index methodology page.

About Vizaeo

Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.