Feed it to your favorite LLM

Guide

AI Visibility for Medicare Advisors

Short answer

All 3 answers pointed to free state counseling, and 2 of 3 said to go there before a broker. The Tampa answer named six options and found no independent ranking. We asked 3 buyer questions on 2026-10-14 and counted each raw answer by hand.

The AI Visibility Index: Medicare advisors

We asked 3 buyer questions on 2026-10-14, and Claude answered all 3. The metro was Tampa, Florida, and 1 of the 3 questions named it. All 3 answers came back usable, and the how-to-choose answer ran without web access. Every count below is out of 3 answers.

Who the models name

Only the Tampa answer named a program or a firm, so each name below is in 1 of 3 answers. It called them the ones it would call first, "not a verified 'best' list."

  • SHINE (Serving Health Insurance Needs of Elders): first, as "free, unbiased, and confidential" state counseling with no sales commission. The answer noted SHINE cannot enroll you.
  • Medicare Information Project (Brandon): second, as "the best-documented broker." It cited a Better Business Bureau (BBB) A+ rating, 0 complaints in 3 years, 53 reviews, and a 2010 founding. It was the only broker the answer checked against an outside source.
  • Timothy Gibson, HealthPlan4U (Tampa): third. His site claims 16 years in Medicare, 17 insurers, and Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco and 8 more counties. The answer did not confirm those claims.
  • Robin Dall, RobinsWisdom (Parrish): ranked lower, as "based in Parrish" and representing "only up to 10 insurers." The answer noted she is "licensed since 2013."
  • Alliance Health Group (Tampa) and TD Coverage (Clearwater): from a search summary of Google ratings. The listing pages returned errors, so the answer did not confirm the ratings.

The other two answers named no advisor.

Where the models send clients

  • Free state counseling: 3 of 3 answers. The Tampa answer named SHINE. The other two named the State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP), through shiphelp.org, a state search, or 1-800-MEDICARE.
  • Medicare.gov: 2 of 3. One named Plan Finder. One linked the pages on joining a plan and on when to buy Medigap.
  • A state license lookup: 2 of 3. The Tampa answer named the Florida Department of Financial Services licensee search and said it did not run it.
  • 1 of 3 each: the BBB, unverified Google review counts, Lantern listing pages (both fetches failed), the agent's own site, and a WMNF article on SHINE.

What the models judge on

  • Both paths, Advantage and Medigap: 3 of 3 answers. The choosing answer wanted Part D quoted beside Medigap.
  • No sales commission: 2 of 3. Both said the state counselors earn none.
  • Who pays the broker: 2 of 3, both said the insurer pays. The choosing answer added that federal rules cap Advantage and Part D commissions and that Medigap commissions vary.
  • An active license: 2 of 3.
  • More than one carrier: 2 of 3. The Tampa answer set 17 insurers against a cap of 10. The choosing answer said to ask how many carriers a broker sells in the county, and which major ones are missing.
  • Enrollment dates: 2 of 3. Both gave October 15 to December 7. The deadline answer said the 6-month Medigap window "does not repeat every year" and quoted Medicare.gov: after it, "you may not be able to buy a Medigap policy, or it may cost more."
  • Premium versus total cost, and doctors, drugs and networks: 2 of 3. The choosing answer warned against "$0 premium" as the main pitch.
  • Outside proof, years in the work, and star ratings: 1 of 3 each. The Tampa answer could not verify the stars.
  • Red flags: 1 of 3. The choosing answer listed unsolicited contact, pressure, an early ask for the Medicare number, and silence on pay.
  • Travel or time in two states, as a Medigap reason: 1 of 3.
  • Stays with you: 1 of 3. The choosing answer said to ask for a plan review every fall and help when a claim is denied.
  • Local references: 1 of 3. The choosing answer said to ask friends, family, or your doctor's office staff.

How to improve your AI visibility as a Medicare advisor

Publish the facts these answers already look up.

AI access

Allow GPTBot, ClaudeBot, and PerplexityBot in the robots file. Put the license number, the counties, and the carrier count in HTML, not only in a PDF. The Tampa answer quoted a broker site and could not confirm the claims. Link the Florida license record and the BBB profile if you have one.

AI business profile

Say whether you are independent or captive, and name the carriers you sell in Hillsborough County. Say whether you sell Advantage, Medigap, and Part D. Say who pays you, since the choosing answer flagged silence on pay. Name the counties, and say you are not Medicare and not SHINE.

Identity tags

Add InsuranceAgency data with the legal name, address, phone, and area served. Add a Person block for each agent, with the Florida license number as an identifier. Use the same name as the Department of Financial Services record. The Tampa answer told readers to check that record and then skipped the check.

Answer bank

Publish the four windows on your site:

  • Initial Enrollment: 7 months around the month you turn 65.
  • Open Enrollment: October 15 to December 7.
  • The Advantage switch window: January 1 to March 31.
  • The 6-month Medigap window, which starts with Part B at 65 or older.

Say what changes when that Medigap window closes. Compare both paths on doctors, drugs, travel, and the out-of-pocket maximum. Tell readers to take the written plan ID to SHINE, then to Plan Finder.

Google profile

Set the category to insurance agency. Describe an independent broker who sells both paths and holds a Florida license. Do not write that you are from Medicare. Post fall hours, when the choosing answer said marketing is loudest. Keep one phone number on the profile, the site, and the license.

Listing consistency

Match name, address, phone, and carrier count across Google, the BBB, the site, and the license record. The Tampa answer trusted the broker an outside page could confirm. Fix listings that fail to load.

Freshness and measurement

Update the enrollment page before October 15, and update carriers when an appointment changes. Each quarter, ask an AI assistant who is the best Medicare advisor in your city, how to choose one, and Advantage versus Medigap with the deadline. Save the answers. Note whether you appear, or only SHINE and Medicare.gov appear.

Medicare Advisors-specific plays

  • Point to free counseling. All 3 answers named free state counseling (SHIP; in Florida, SHINE). Say on your site how you work alongside it.
  • Publish the carrier count for the county. Two answers judged that number, and one answer ranked a broker lower for a cap of 10 insurers and a base outside Tampa.
  • Put the Medigap clock on the page. One answer said the Medigap window does not come back; another said a later switch can mean health questions.
  • Do not headline a $0 premium. Two answers said the premium is not the full cost.
  • Link the Florida licensee search next to your license number. The Tampa answer named that search and did not run it.

How this index is made

We asked 3 buyer questions to one AI engine family, Claude, through command-line engines on 2026-10-14. We store each answer raw in a public dataset and count it by hand. Three answers from one engine is a thin sample. The how-to-choose answer had no web access. We refresh the dataset in waves, so this page is one snapshot of a time series, and the Index methodology page explains the full method.

About Vizaeo

Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.