The AI Visibility Index for Insurance Claim Lawyers
Short answer
The one answer asked to recommend Tampa firms named two policyholder firms from memory, because it could not search the web. Fees, bad faith, and a match to the claim each appeared in 3 of 3 answers. The method asks buyer questions, stores every raw answer, and counts.
The AI Visibility Index: Insurance claim lawyers
Three buyer questions were asked on October 14, 2026. Only the recommendation question named Tampa, FL; the other two named no place. Claude answered who to hire and whether counsel can force payment of a denied hurricane roof claim. Grok answered how to choose. All 3 answers were substantive. Counts below use those 3 answers.
Who the models name
Merlin Law Group and Morgan & Morgan each appear in 1 of 3 answers. Only the recommendation answer named firms.
That answer called Merlin Law Group the best-known policyholder property firm in Florida, with a Tampa office, and named founder Chip Merlin and the Property Insurance Coverage Law blog. It called Morgan & Morgan a large consumer firm with an insurance-claims group, and warned about junior staff.
The same answer named Carlton Fields, Shutts & Bowen, and Kubicki Draper as insurer-defense firms. Each appears in 1 of 3. The answer said not to hire them against your own insurer. The answer could not name a Tampa bad-faith firm without a live check.
The answer could not search the web, so the names are a memory list. This page does not verify or endorse any lawyer.
Where the models send clients
A bar lookup appears in 2 of 3 answers. One answer named the Florida Bar search at floridabar.org. The other said to use the state bar search, and did not name Florida.
ABA pages appear in 1 of 3. That answer cited the questions-to-ask page, the model fee rule, and the page on settling a fee. The NAIC public-adjuster model act appears in 1 of 3.
A state insurance department appears in 1 of 3, as a place to complain. That answer mentioned mediation programs and named none. No answer named Avvo, Martindale, Super Lawyers, Chambers, or Google.
What the models judge on
A practice matched to the dispute appears in 3 of 3 answers. Fees, bad faith, and contingency each appear in 3 of 3.
Policyholder work, set against insurer defense, appears in 2 of 3. A written fee agreement, trial experience, and bar discipline each appear in 2 of 3. A named lawyer on the file appears in 1 of 3, the choice answer. A warning about junior staff appears in 1 of 3, the recommendation answer.
Matching-file share, recent similar matters, and suit deadlines each appear in 2 of 3. Appraisal, a public adjuster as a separate option, and bringing the policy and photos each appear in 2 of 3.
The recommendation answer cited Florida reforms SB 2-A and HB 837, from 2022 and 2023. That point appears in 1 of 3. It said those laws mostly ended insurer-paid fees after a policyholder win, so fewer firms now take small property claims on contingency.
The choice answer said many policies cut the time to sue, sometimes to one or two years from the loss. The denial answer said deadlines are strict, then asked which state the house is in. The denial question named no state, so that answer asked for one.
The denial answer split a coverage fight from an amount fight. An amount fight may use appraisal, with an appraiser for each side and a neutral umpire. That split appears in 1 of 3. Denial reasons in that answer were wear and tear, the hurricane deductible, a late report, and a cosmetic exclusion.
The choice answer cited ABA text calling a typical contingent fee often one-third to 40 percent of the recovery. It compared expenses taken before the percentage with expenses taken after. Only the choice answer warned about a guaranteed result and a lawyer who calls first after a storm. It also warned about a vague fee deal, a hidden referral, and inflated repairs.
How to improve your AI visibility as an insurance claim lawyer
Publish your side first.
AI access
Keep hurricane, wind, water, and fire pages in plain HTML, with the phone in text. Allow AI crawlers, and keep claim files off the public site.
AI business profile
State in the first lines that you represent policyholders, not insurers. Name the perils you take, and name the lawyer who tries the case. Say how you charge after the fee-shift change one answer described.
Identity tags
Add LegalService and Attorney markup with the Florida Bar number. Mark up each peril you handle (hurricane, wind, water, fire) as its own Service item. State in the description field that you represent policyholders only, since the naming answer sorted firms by that side.
Answer bank
Answer whether counsel can force a hurricane insurer to pay. Separate a coverage denial from appraisal. Ask first for the policy, the denial, photos, and a roofer report. Say how your fee differs from a public adjuster fee.
Google profile
Show the Tampa address and true after-storm hours. Ask clients who consent for reviews that name the work: a denial reversed, an appraisal handled, or the adjuster fee explained. Do not ask for the settlement amount.
Listing consistency
Match name, city, phone, and bar number on the Florida Bar record and the site. Drop an old defense line if you now sue insurers. The choice answer said to hire someone else when a lawyer also defends insurers.
Freshness and measurement
When a statute changes a deadline or a fee rule, date the new page. Re-ask the same three questions each quarter, and record which firms and sources each answer names.
Insurance Claim Lawyers-specific plays
Use these plays for denied property claims.
Name the side you take
Two answers separated policyholder lawyers from insurer-defense lawyers. Put that side in the title and the opening lines.
Publish the denial reasons
The denial answer listed wear and tear, the deductible, late notice, and a cosmetic exclusion. Give each reason a short page on the proof you want. Call the pages your process, not a promise of payment.
Explain appraisal
Two answers mentioned appraisal. Say who picks the appraiser and the umpire, and which fights stay in court.
Show both fees
One answer warned that counsel and a public adjuster can both take a share of the same check. State the order: expenses, your percentage, then any adjuster commission.
State the fee after reforms
One answer said SB 2-A and HB 837 mostly ended insurer-paid fees after a win. Say whether you still take small claims, and whether the fee is contingent.
Place the page in Tampa
The recommendation answer sent readers to the Florida Bar search. Repeat Tampa, Florida, and the Florida Bar on every service page.
How this index is made
Buyer questions went to command-line engines on October 14, 2026. Claude and Grok wrote the answers. The public dataset stores each raw answer. Later waves refresh the dataset, so this page is one snapshot. Three answers is a small sample. One answer could not search, and two questions named no place. The Index methodology page explains the full method.
About Vizaeo
Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.