AI Visibility for Criminal Defense Lawyers in Columbus, OH
Short answer
In Columbus, no private criminal defense lawyer appeared in both sampled answers. Both answers sent readers to the Supreme Court of Ohio attorney directory. Vizaeo asked 2 buyer questions in English to 2 AI engines on 2026-10-18 and tallied the raw answers by hand.
The AI Visibility Index: Criminal defense lawyers in Columbus
Vizaeo asked 2 questions in English on 2026-10-18, one to grok and one to claude-vizaeo. The naming question asked who the best criminal defense lawyers in Columbus are, and why. The choosing question asked how to choose, what to look for, what to avoid, and the usual charge. The sample is 2 answers. The naming answer used Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers, and Best Law Firms. The choosing answer had no web search. It called the fees estimates, and it assumed Columbus, Ohio.
Who the models name
Because the choosing answer named no private lawyer, each name below is 1 of 2. The naming answer said peer lists are not win rates.
- Samuel H. Shamansky, Samuel H. Shamansky Co., LPA, 1 of 2. 523 South Third Street. (614) 242-3939. First call for a serious felony. Super Lawyers from 2004 through 2027. Firm Tier 2 in Columbus for 2026, for criminal defense and white-collar work.
- Bradley P. Koffel, Koffel Brininger Nesbitt, 1 of 2. 1801 Watermark Drive, Suite 350. (614) 756-5310. Criminal work only. A hard felony, a sex case, or a public case. Firm Tier 2 for DUI/DWI defense in 2026.
- Shawn R. Dominy, Dominy Law Firm, 1 of 2. 7716 Rivers Edge Drive, Suite B. (614) 717-1177. The 2026 pick for OVI or a vehicular homicide or assault. Lawyer of the Year for DUI/DWI defense in 2026 and 2024. Firm Tier 1 for that work and Tier 2 for general criminal defense in 2026.
- Daniel J. Sabol, Sabol Mallory, 1 of 2. 743 South Front Street. (614) 300-5088. NBTA certificate in criminal trial law. A Lawyer Legion list called him the only local holder. Chase Mallory, same firm, 1 of 2, on Super Lawyers for DUI work from 2024 through 2027.
- James P. Tyack and Jonathan T. Tyack, Tyack Law, each 1 of 2. 536 South High Street. (614) 221-1342. Strongest firm label in that answer. Tier 1 in Columbus for 2026, criminal defense and white-collar. The firm also does injury work. Ask who stands up.
- Stephen E. Palmer, Palmer Legal Defense, 1 of 2. 511 South High Street. (614) 224-6142. Super Lawyers from 2011 through 2027, from OVI through homicide and white-collar work.
- David H. Thomas, Taft, 1 of 2. 41 South High Street. (614) 334-6199. White-collar, federal, public-official, and health-care fraud.
- Diane Menashe, The Menashe Law Group, 1 of 2. 1330 Dublin Road. No phone given. Boutique white-collar hire. American College of Trial Lawyers.
Franklin County Public Defender: 1 of 2, choosing answer only. No address and no phone. The naming answer named no defender office.
Where the models send clients
Supreme Court of Ohio attorney directory: 2 of 2. The naming answer gave supremecourt.ohio.gov/AttorneySearch/. The choosing answer named the directory and gave no URL.
Columbus Bar Association lawyer referral service: 1 of 2, the choosing answer. No phone and no URL. Peer lists in the naming answer, each 1 of 2: Best Lawyers, Super Lawyers, Best Law Firms, Martindale-Hubbell, Columbus CEO, Avvo, and Lawyer Legion. The naming answer said Super Lawyers takes no more than 5 percent of lawyers in the state. It said that cap is not a win rate.
What the models judge on
License status and public discipline, through the Ohio directory: 2 of 2. The person who will stand in the courtroom: 2 of 2. A charge that lawyer has tried in the court that has the case: 2 of 2. A meeting with more than one lawyer: 2 of 2. The naming answer said meet two. The choosing answer said call three. Skepticism of ads: 2 of 2. The naming answer said peer lists, not Google ads. The choosing answer said ad spend is not skill.
Both answers used OVI for the Ohio driving charge. The naming answer also quoted the Best Lawyers category DUI/DWI. Franklin County appears in 2 of 2. The building names do not. Municipal Court, Common Pleas, a suburban mayor's court, and the Southern District of Ohio are 1 of 2, all in the choosing answer.
Board certificates do not match across the two answers. The naming answer used the National Board of Trial Advocacy for Sabol only. The choosing answer pointed at Ohio State Bar Association certification in criminal law, with extra testing and peer review. Each path is 1 of 2.
The choosing answer, in 1 of 2, wanted a practice that is mostly criminal. It flagged a promised dismissal, a promise of no jail, and pressure to pay on the spot. It flagged a junior in court, a vague fee, a fee that depends on winning, a nonrefundable label with no refund sentence, and slow replies.
Choosing-answer fees are labeled rough estimates, not Columbus data. Confidence in that answer is low to moderate, and low on the serious cases. A minor misdemeanor is about 750 to 2,500 dollars. A first OVI or ordinary misdemeanor, on a plea, is about 1,500 to 5,000 dollars. Trial is often 2,500 to 5,000 dollars more. A fourth-degree or fifth-degree felony is about 5,000 to 15,000 dollars. A serious felony is about 15,000 to 50,000 dollars or more. A homicide or complex federal case is about 50,000 to 100,000 dollars or more. Experts and investigators are usually extra.
How to improve your AI visibility as a criminal defense lawyer in Columbus
Publish the Franklin County court, the Ohio directory link, and the fee stage as HTML.
AI access
Allow GPTBot, OAI-SearchBot, ClaudeBot, PerplexityBot, and Google-Extended. Serve the bio as HTML. Put Municipal Court, Common Pleas, or the Southern District of Ohio in the first lines. Put the registration number in the text.
AI business profile
Say if the work is OVI, a Common Pleas felony, or white-collar. Link the Ohio directory record. Name who stands up. State the plea fee and the trial add-on. Do not promise no jail.
Identity tags
Mark the firm as a LegalService and each lawyer as a Person, with jobTitle Attorney. Put the Ohio directory profile in sameAs. Menashe had no phone in the naming answer. Publish one.
Answer bank
Write separate pages for OVI, a low felony, and white-collar work. The naming answer switched tracks for the last of those. Put your fee on the page. The only dollars here were unverified estimates.
Google profile
Use Criminal justice attorney as the category. Ask clients to name the court, never the charge. This cell said to ignore Google ads.
Listing consistency
Match name, street, and phone on the Ohio directory, the Columbus Bar referral list, and the site. South High, South Third, Dublin Road, and Watermark Drive are different offices here.
Freshness and measurement
Date the fee page. Recheck the Ohio directory when a lawyer leaves. Re-ask both questions monthly in two assistants.
Criminal defense lawyers-specific plays in Columbus
- Two certificates. NBTA showed up for one lawyer. The OSBA certificate showed up only in the choosing answer. Name the issuer.
- Say OVI. Both answers used it. The Best Lawyers category here still says DUI/DWI.
- Name the building. Municipal Court, Common Pleas, a mayor's court, and the Southern District are four hires.
- Two benches. Thomas at Taft and Menashe were the white-collar names, not the felony-trial names.
- One court date. The choosing answer said to call three lawyers and to write the date down.
How this index is made
Vizaeo asked these buyer questions in English on 2026-10-18, through grok and claude-vizaeo. Raw answers sit in a public dataset. Later waves refresh them, so this page is one snapshot. The sample is 2 answers. The choosing answer had no web access, assumed Columbus, Ohio, and labeled the fees as estimates. Treat every count as thin. The full method lives on the Index methodology page.
About Vizaeo
Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.