Feed it to your favorite LLM

Guide

AI visibility for appellate lawyers

Short answer

The one Washington, DC list answer named 5 appellate lawyers, each with a firm biography as the source and 4 with a stated Supreme Court record. All 3 sampled answers raised fees, and 2 of 3 asked for clear or written fee estimates. The tally uses 3 raw answers from October 14, 2026.

The AI Visibility Index: appellate lawyers

On October 14, 2026, OpenAI Codex answered who the best appellate lawyers are in Washington, DC, and what an appeal costs after a trial loss. Anthropic Claude answered how to choose one. Only the list question named Washington, DC. All 3 probes returned usable answers. The how-to-choose answer said it "didn't look anything up."

Who the models name

Each lawyer below appeared in 1 of 3 answers, the list answer. The list answer framed its picks for "major federal appeals and U.S. Supreme Court litigation."

  1. Lisa Blatt, of a Washington, DC firm, for trademark, copyright, pharmaceutical, and employment appeals. The answer cited the firm's report of 57 Supreme Court arguments.
  2. Kannon Shanmugam, Davis Polk, for complex commercial appeals, with 40 Supreme Court arguments and more than 150 appeals.
  3. Seth Waxman, WilmerHale, a former U.S. Solicitor General with 90 Supreme Court arguments, for patent and regulatory cases.
  4. Neal Katyal, Milbank, a former Acting Solicitor General, for constitutional and government-power disputes.
  5. Paul Clement, Clement & Murphy, a former Solicitor General with extensive Supreme Court experience, and an office in Alexandria, VA.

The list answer named no lawyer for a local DC criminal, family, housing, or smaller civil appeal. It said it would "tailor the shortlist" around the DC Court of Appeals for those cases. The other 2 answers named no lawyer.

Where the models send clients

  • Firm biography pages appeared in 1 of 3 answers, as the source for all 5 names.
  • Chambers appeared in 1 of 3 answers, for an office location.
  • Federal court websites appeared in 1 of 3 answers, for deadlines, the $605 filing fee, and reversal statistics.
  • The state bar appeared in 1 of 3 answers, for referrals, the appellate practice section, and discipline checks.
  • The American Academy of Appellate Lawyers appeared in 1 of 3 answers.
  • Published appellate opinions, which "name the lawyers who argued them," appeared in 1 of 3 answers.
  • A referral from the trial lawyer appeared in 1 of 3 answers.

What the models judge on

  • Fee terms appeared in 3 of 3 answers. The list answer named fees among items to settle before hiring. The how-to answer asked for clear fees. The cost answer asked for a written estimate covering "record review, transcripts, briefing, oral argument, and any bond."
  • Subject-area fit appeared in 2 of 3 answers.
  • Experience in the specific appellate court appeared in 2 of 3 answers.
  • Who writes the brief and who argues appeared in 2 of 3 answers.
  • The notice-of-appeal deadline appeared in 2 of 3 answers. The how-to answer said the notice is often due within about 30 days, and sooner in some criminal cases. The cost answer gave federal deadlines: 30 days for a civil appeal, generally 60 days when a federal government party is involved, and 14 days for a criminal defendant.
  • The standard of review appeared in 2 of 3 answers.
  • Post-trial motions appeared in 2 of 3 answers.
  • An honest view of the odds appeared in 2 of 3 answers. One said "most appeals fail." The other cited federal reversal rates and said they are "not your personal chances."
  • Supreme Court argument counts and Solicitor General service appeared in 1 of 3 answers.
  • Writing samples appeared in 1 of 3 answers, called "the best predictor of quality."
  • Board certification in appellate law and an appellate clerkship appeared in 1 of 3 answers.
  • A practice that is mainly appeals appeared in 1 of 3 answers.

How to improve your AI visibility as an appellate lawyer

AI access

  1. Publish your biography, argued cases, and selected briefs as text pages, not only as PDFs.
  2. Allow AI crawlers in your robots file. Then fetch your biography as a crawler and confirm the argued cases come back as text.

AI business profile

  1. Open your biography with your name, firm, office address, and the courts you practice in, such as the DC Court of Appeals or the D.C. Circuit.
  2. State what share of your practice is appeals.
  3. List clerkships, board certification, and government service with dates.

Identity tags

  1. Mark each lawyer as a person with appellate law as the practice area, and the firm as a legal service.
  2. Add bar admissions, courts of admission, and memberships as structured fields.
  3. Tag each argued case with its court, year, and subject.

Answer bank

Write one short answer per question clients ask after a trial loss:

  1. What is the deadline to file a notice of appeal in DC Superior Court or federal court?
  2. What does an appeal cost, and how do you bill: flat, hourly, or staged?
  3. What standard of review applies, and why does it matter for my odds?
  4. Should I file post-trial motions first?
  5. Who will write the brief and argue the case?
  6. Can I see briefs you filed?

Google profile

  1. Choose appellate attorney or the closest legal category, and fill in hours.
  2. Name the courts and subjects you handle in the description.
  3. Reply to reviews without revealing client details.

Listing consistency

  1. Match name, firm, and address on your firm site, Google, the DC Bar, Chambers, and other legal directories.
  2. Keep one biography URL per lawyer, and use that same URL on your site and every directory.

Freshness and measurement

  1. Update argued-case lists after each decision.
  2. Rerun the three index questions each wave and save every raw answer with its engine and date.
  3. Track whether lawyers for local DC appeals start appearing, since this batch named none.

Appellate Lawyers-specific plays

Fill the local-appeal gap

The list answer named only advocates for major federal and Supreme Court appeals and no lawyer for local DC appeals. Publish pages on DC Court of Appeals work by subject: criminal, family, housing, civil.

Publish the deadline page

Two answers stressed the notice-of-appeal deadline, and one gave 30 days civil and 14 days criminal in federal court. Post the civil and criminal notice deadlines for each court you handle, with the rule cited, and say how fast you can review a judgment.

Put writing samples online

One answer called briefs "the best predictor of quality" and noted that briefs are public records. Post redacted briefs with the court and year.

Explain cost against odds plainly

Two answers discussed the odds, and one weighed them against cost. Publish your fee structure and explain the standard of review in plain words. Never promise a result.

How this index is made

Buyer questions went to CLI engines on October 14, 2026, and the public dataset stores each raw answer. This sample is thin: 3 answers from 2 engines, and only 1 answer named lawyers. The how-to-choose answer used no sources. The factory refreshes probes in waves, so this page is one snapshot in a time series. The Index methodology page explains the full method.

About Vizaeo

Vizaeo is an AI visibility service for law firms. It measures whether ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, and Perplexity name your firm when clients ask for a lawyer, then applies the fixes that make a firm readable and quotable by AI assistants, with proof of each change. The Vizaeo sprint is $499 for 14 days of done-for-you fixes, with re-measurement at 30, 60, and 90 days against your baseline. If we miss the fix list, you get a refund.